Raiders fan, left

The unofficial archive

RAIDERS
TRAGEDY

Commitment to Embarrassment

Raiders fan, right

Canon, With Arrests: 49ers 38, Raiders 17

Five turnovers in one half. Santa Clara police logged 11 arrests and 45 ejections. Both were avoidable. Neither was a surprise. Seattle comes to Allegiant next.

Last week

49ers 38, Raiders 17

Levi's Stadium, Santa Clara, Calif. · Sun Nov 8 · Raiders 4–5, 49ers 7–1

Ladies and gentlemen, False Hope, Vol. 2 has closed after a one-week engagement. The museum thanks you for visiting. Please return to the permanent collection.

The Raiders came back to the Bay Area for the first time since leaving Oakland (raiders.com) and lost by 21 (raiders.com; CBS News Bay Area; Review-Journal). They turned it over five times after halftime, three times in field-goal range, once directly into a touchdown (raiders.com). It was the sixth straight game the defense allowed at least 30 points (raiders.com). The losing is canon. The rest of Sunday is covered below, and it is not funny.

AFC West, after Week 9: Broncos 7–2, Chiefs 6–2, Raiders 4–5, Chargers 0–8 (FOX Sports; Silver and Black Pride). Kansas City beat the Jets 35–12 (Silver and Black Pride). The Jets team the Raiders needed a kick return and an end-zone interception to survive. The Chiefs needed neither. Different building. Different century.

The play for the museum: the first snap of the second half

Cousins bobbled the snap. He picked it up. He underthrew Tre Tucker. Rookie linebacker Jaden Dugger caught it and returned it 35 yards for a touchdown (raiders.com; NBC Sports Bay Area). One play, 17 seconds, 28–10. A fifth-round rookie (NBC Bay Area) set the tone for the half. The Raiders' quarterback merely provided the ball. Mount it under glass.

49ers honor roll: Fred Warner and Jaden Dugger

Warner forced a fumble from Brock Bowers, his NFL-leading fifth of the season, and recovered another in his own end zone after Upton Stout punched the ball from Michael Mayer at the 1 (NBC Sports Bay Area; raiders.com). Dugger's pick-six made him the first 49ers rookie with one since 2020 (NBC Bay Area). Honorable mention: the 49ers defense as a whole, five takeaways in one half, its most in a game since 2014 (NBC Sports Bay Area). San Francisco also ran for 190 yards (raiders.com). The Bay Area already has a team. It is 7–1.

Raiders exhibit of the week: five second-half turnovers

Three interceptions and two lost fumbles (NBC Sports Bay Area). Cousins' first three-interception game since Week 13 of 2024 (raiders.com). Two fumbles came with the Raiders threatening to score, one at the 1-yard line (raiders.com). "That football is my entire life," Mayer said afterward (raiders.com). This publication believes him. It also notes the football is now San Francisco's.

The nepo line: Klint Kubiak's postgame diagnosis: "When you're in position to throw the ball every down, starting in the second quarter, you're going to throw interceptions" (raiders.com). His team ran 15 times for 24 yards (raiders.com). His father, Gary, won a Super Bowl as a head coach. Klint inherited the surname, the headset and the explanation. Not the outcome.

Tom Brady, minority owner, minority impact: Tom Brady built a career on not giving the ball away. He then bought a piece of a team that gave it away five times in a half. Seven rings on the hand. Zero sense in the wallet. The Brayders are 4–5. The Tommy Boys watched from a suite in the city their franchise abandoned.

Raiders who scored points, ranked by how much it mattered (none)

  • Kirk Cousins (6, goal-line TD run, Q2): Mayer pushed him in from behind (raiders.com). He then threw three interceptions and fed one to a rookie for six (raiders.com; NBC Sports Bay Area). Cousins, you scored one touchdown for each team. Generous to a fault. Mostly the fault.
  • Brock Bowers (6, 21-yd TD catch, Q3): Seven catches, 111 yards (raiders.com). Then Warner punched the ball loose and the 49ers recovered (raiders.com; NBC Sports Bay Area). Bowers, you were the best player on the Raiders' offense. That is the insult.
  • Matt Gay (5, 50-yd FG plus two PATs): (raiders.com). Gay, your 50-yarder cut it to 11 at halftime. Your teammates then made sure you never got another three-point attempt worth discussing.

Opposing-fan note: See the special report below.

House read: No false hope this week. Just the regular kind of hope, removed five times.

Autopsy

Christian McCaffrey scored from the 1. Brock Purdy scored from the 1. San Francisco led 14–0 after two possessions (raiders.com). Cousins answered with a goal-line touchdown run. Purdy beat a blitz with a 12-yard touchdown to McCaffrey. Gay's 50-yarder made it 21–10 at halftime (raiders.com). Then the second half. Dugger's pick-six on the first snap (raiders.com; NBC Sports Bay Area). Cousins hit Bowers for 21 yards and a touchdown. Rookie safety Treydan Stukes intercepted Purdy (raiders.com). Two plays later, Warner punched the ball from Bowers and Dre Greenlaw recovered. Stout punched it from Mayer at the 1, and Warner recovered for a touchback (raiders.com; NBC Sports Bay Area). Purdy hit Jordan Watkins for 37 yards (raiders.com). The Raiders reached the 1 again. Mayer's touchdown was erased by offensive pass interference. Renardo Green intercepted Cousins (raiders.com). Malik Mustapha added the fifth takeaway (NBC Sports Bay Area). The 49ers did not need to be perfect. They needed to wait.

SPECIAL REPORT: Santa Clara, Sunday

This publication condemns the violence at Levi's Stadium on Sunday without qualification. People were knocked unconscious. Two people went to the hospital (NBC Bay Area). Nobody's rivalry is worth that. This publication does not name fans, does not link the videos and does not cheer anyone's injuries. Here is what was reported.

The facts, as reported

  • 11 arrests, 45 ejections. Santa Clara Police Lt. Eric Lagergren reported 11 arrests and 45 ejections during the event, with several incidents still under investigation (Review-Journal; Las Vegas Sun/Bay Area News Group; NBC Bay Area). CBS News Bay Area reported "dozens" ejected.
  • The charges. Per the police arrest log, four people were arrested on suspicion of fighting in a public place, one of them also on a drug-possession charge. Seven were arrested on suspicion of public intoxication (Review-Journal). The San Francisco Standard, citing department records, described the seven as alcohol-related disorderly conduct arrests and reported the 11 as nine men and two women, ages 28 to 51 (SF Standard).
  • Where. Fights were reported in the stands, the parking lot and the surrounding area (CBS News Bay Area). NBC Bay Area reported the violence spread from the stands to the parking lot, with video from the upper deck and outside the stadium (NBC Bay Area).
  • Hospitalizations. Two people were hospitalized and have since been released (NBC Bay Area).
  • The parking-lot video. One video shows at least seven people in a brawl in the stadium parking lot, with two men left apparently unconscious (Review-Journal). Other people continued to hit and kick people on the ground while they were unconscious (CBS News Bay Area). A post of that video on X had over three million views by Monday afternoon (Review-Journal). Outlets said they could not independently verify the video or who was in it (SF Standard; Las Vegas Sun/Bay Area News Group).
  • The upper-deck video. Another video with over three million views shows two fans fighting in the upper level before falling down the section into other fans (Review-Journal). "The validity of every video cannot be confirmed" (Review-Journal).
  • Security. NBC Bay Area reported a security presence involving some 30 outside agencies (NBC Bay Area).
  • Uncooperative victims. Some fights involved victims who were "not willing to cooperate with the police investigations," Lagergren said (Las Vegas Sun/Bay Area News Group; CBS News Bay Area).
  • Who they were. "It is not known if any of the fans involved were from Southern Nevada" (Review-Journal). It is not clear whether any of the four fighting arrests came from the incidents seen on social media (Review-Journal).

What the police said

"Incidents of violence at large-scale events in Santa Clara will not be tolerated. The Department strictly enforces the law and holds individuals accountable for criminal conduct. We will seek to arrest the individuals responsible for the fan-on-fan violence at the event." — Lt. Eric Lagergren, Santa Clara Police Department (Review-Journal; Las Vegas Sun/Bay Area News Group)

"The Santa Clara Police Department is aware of a video circulating online of an assault that occurred outside the stadium today. This incident is part of an active and ongoing investigation." — Lagergren, statement to the San Francisco Chronicle, as quoted by the SF Standard

What the 49ers said

"We have a zero-tolerance policy for violence at Levi's Stadium. The Santa Clara Police Department, our security, and guest services teams responded to several incidents throughout Sunday's game. We are grateful to all personnel for their swift response and dedication to maintaining a safe environment for all fans." — 49ers spokesperson (CBS News Bay Area; SF Standard)

No Raiders statement on the fights was found in any source reviewed for this report.

What the players saw

"We were seeing people fight in the stands," 49ers defensive end Keion White said (CBS News Bay Area; Review-Journal). "For us, you can never let be bigger that what it is, it's just the next opponent" (CBS News Bay Area). The players kept their composure. The paying customers did not.

What an expert said

"There could have been deaths associated with these savage beatings," said Michael Leininger, a law-enforcement analyst and retired San Jose police detective (NBC Bay Area). He suggested officials re-evaluate staffing and alcohol sales (NBC Bay Area).

The other video

CBS News Bay Area also reported videos of Raiders and 49ers fans tailgating together before the game, dancing to live bands and DJs in the parking lot (CBS News Bay Area). That happened too. Most people came to watch football. Most people went home.

This is not new

  • 2011: A preseason game at Candlestick Park was marred by violence inside and outside the stadium, including two shootings, fights in the stands and a fan beaten unconscious in a bathroom. The annual preseason game was cancelled in 2012 (CBS News Bay Area; SF Standard).
  • 2018: The Raiders' last regular-season visit to Levi's Stadium, on Nov. 1, 2018, led to 32 arrests, mostly for public intoxication (SF Standard; Review-Journal).
  • 2023: Two people were stabbed in a fight involving fans in jerseys from both teams at a Santa Clara In-N-Out after a 49ers preseason game (SF Standard).
  • For scale: Seven arrests were made at Levi's on Oct. 19 when the 49ers played the Broncos (Review-Journal). Sunday was smaller than 2018 and larger than an ordinary Sunday.

This publication's position

Both fan bases were in those parking lots. The reporting does not say who started anything, and this publication will not pretend it does.

What this publication will say is about the franchise. For decades the Raiders sold menace as a brand. The skulls, the costumes, the "outlaw" mythology. It moved 500 miles to Las Vegas and kept the merchandise. Brands like that do not throw punches. They do sell the idea that throwing one is part of the experience. Then a Sunday like this happens, and the press release says "zero tolerance."

Mark Davis said last week that opposing fans keep taking over his stadium because "we haven't given them anything to be proud of yet" (Review-Journal). Correct. A pick-six on the first snap of the half is not something to be proud of. Neither is a parking lot. Neither is a fight over a team that lost by 21.

Watch the game. Boo the team. This publication recommends it weekly. Then go home.

If you witnessed the incidents or have video, Santa Clara police ask you to call 408-615-4700 or the anonymous tip line at 408-615-4847 (Review-Journal; SF Standard; CBS News Bay Area).

Next week

Seahawks at Raiders: The Champions Are Visiting

When / where / channel: Sunday, Nov. 15, 2026 · 2:05 p.m. MT (1:05 p.m. PT / 4:05 p.m. ET) · Allegiant Stadium, Las Vegas · CBS (raiders.com; Seahawks.com).

AFC West: Broncos 7–2, Chiefs 6–2, Raiders 4–5, Chargers 0–8 (FOX Sports; Silver and Black Pride).

Why Seattle is entitled to ruin them

  • The title. Seattle is the defending champion (raiders.com). The Raiders are defending 4–5.
  • The record. Seahawks 5–4 (FOX Sports; Seahawks.com). Raiders 1–3 at home (FOX Sports). Allegiant is a fine place for visitors.
  • The defense. Six straight games allowing at least 30 points (raiders.com). Seattle can count to 30.

Injuries as reported

  • G Trey Zuhn III: Took a blow to the head in the third quarter against San Francisco and was evaluated for a concussion; Caleb Rogers replaced him at right guard (CBS Sports/RotoWire). Status for Week 10 not yet reported.
  • No Week 10 practice reports have been posted. Nothing else is logged here until an approved outlet reports it. This publication wishes everyone on both sidelines well.

Three Keys (from the Seahawks' side)

  • Run it. San Francisco ran for 190 yards (raiders.com).
  • Wait for the ball. Five takeaways in one half last week (raiders.com; NBC Sports Bay Area). Patience pays.
  • Bring your fans. The owner says the stadium is open to them (Review-Journal). Cheer loud. Behave in the parking lot.

Prediction

The Seahawks win. The Raiders fall to 4–6. The owner explains it in the Review-Journal. The minority owner explains nothing. It is written.

Also being built Tape Room and shop.

Tips and hate mail: raiderstragedy@gmail.com